You Can Tune a Carburetor, but You Can’t Tuna Fish

You Can Tune a Carburetor, but You Can’t Tuna Fish

I don’t know where the term “master engine tuner” originated, but I suspect it parallels that of “master piano tuner” because both disciplines transform apparent discord into apparent harmony. In this day of electronically managed engines, we forget that mechanically controlled spark advance curves and carburetor mixtures don’t compensate for changes in barometric pressure and ambient temperature. Fine-tuning carburetors and distributor ignitions to compensate for often discordant barometric and ambient temperature changes is the art and profession of the master engine tuner.

Modern Performance Tuning
*with apologies to the band reo speedwagon. of course, if you were around in the late 1970s and early ’80s, you probably remember reo speedwagon’s seventh  studio album released in 1978 — you can tune a piano but you can’t tuna fish. the album, with hits including “roll with the changes” and “time for me to fly” was reo’s first to make the top 40, peaking at #29. reo speedwagon took its name from the reo speed wagon, a flatbed truck, often outfitted as a firetruck, manufactured by the reo motor car company. (“r.e.o.” are the initials of the company’s founder, ransom eli olds, who also founded oldsmobile, once a division of general motors.) in 1971, gm gave the band rights to the name and logo. Because of the numerous variables in engine applications and latitude in interpretation, no rule of thumb should be accepted as the final word in any type of performance tuning. The “rules of thumb” stated in the following text are just that, rules that are meant only to be guidelines for the beginning engine tuner. With that said, modern precision engine tuning is usually limited to collector cars, street rods and off-road vehicles. Due to their age and the fact that most are driven a limited number of annual miles, most are required to meet only minimal exhaust emissions standards. Nevertheless, proper tuning and maintenance will keep exhaust emissions well within specified emissions levels without undue expense to fuel economy and performance.

Tuning an engine for maximum performance has three basic prerequisites. The first is that the engine must be in good mechanical condition, with the cylinder leakage being as close to zero as possible and the camshaft timing either at specification or slightly advanced from specification. Valve seat widths should not be wider than specified, and the valves should be seated as close to the combustion chamber surface as possible. Valve port pockets also should be machined to allow maximum airflow into the cylinder. Remember, too, that engines with mismatched manifolds, camshafts or cylinder heads will never be responsive to precision tuning techniques.

Second, the carburetor must be compatible with the engine. Most of the OE performance carbs built in the late ’60s and early ’70s can meet emissions standards if they are in good condition. If you’re working on a collector car, an OE “serial-number” carburetor in good condition is nearly worth its weight in gold because it will greatly enhance the performance and value of the vehicle.

If an aftermarket carburetor is used, its capacity should equal the cubic-feet of air per minute (cfm) pumping capability of the engine. Most stock engines pump air at about 80% efficiency and well-prepared racing engines pump air at about 100% efficiency. If, the mathematical pumping capability of a stock engine is 700 cfm at 6,000 rpm, the actual requirement would be 560 cfm (700 x 0.8 = 560) at or near the top of the engine’s power band.

photo 1: oe dual-point distributors are easy to tune if breaker arm tensions and dwell angles are equal. individual dwell is adjusted by disconnecting the opposing points or by insulating the contacts with thin lens-cleaning paper. Third, understand that contact point ignitions are technology from the early 1900s. Dual-point ignitions were designed to add about 6° of dwell angle for better coil saturation at high engine speeds. At best, a well-prepared OE dual-contact point ignition with 34° of dwell can provide adequate spark up to about 7,000 rpm. At worst, a contact distributor with a worn advance plate bushing, distributor shaft or breaker point cam will allow excessive spark timing variation to occur among the engine’s cylinders. In general, a good OE high-performance contact point distributor in good condition should allow no more than 2-3 crankshaft degrees of timing variation per cylinder while most specialty distributors should allow less. See Photo 1.

In earlier times, many high-end shops used distributor testing machines to evaluate high-speed distributor performance. In today’s shop, distributor timing variation can be measured by using an adjustable advance timing light and a harmonic balancer accurately divided into 90° segments on a V8 engine, 120° segments on a six-cylinder engine or 180° segments on a four-cylinder engine. When available, “degreed” harmonic balancers are very desirable for precision distributor tuning.

Dwell angle can be similarly measured by using a modern multimeter to display the duty cycle “on-time” of the contact points. To convert a 60% duty cycle into an 8-cylinder dwell angle, multiply 360° of distributor rotation by 60% (360 x 0.60 = 216° of dwell angle). To convert 216° into dwell angle, divide by the number of cylinders (216/8 = 27° of dwell).

Correct breaker spring tension is extremely important for high-performance applications. Most standard breaker arm tensions test at 18 oz. while high performance points test at 26-plus oz. Keep in mind also that the breaker arm pivot bushing must pivot freely to prevent binding at high engine rpm.

The easiest way to eliminate contact point problems without permanently altering the originality of a collector car is to convert the breaker point ignition to an electronic ignition with one of several kits available from aftermarket performance sources. Most of these kits produce about 27-30° of dwell, which is adequate for average street performance use.

Carburetor Tuning
Most carbureted V8 engines use a “180°” intake manifold design that essentially divides the intake photo 2: this old snap-on mt 460 engine tester features odd and even power balancing. many of these old testers remain operable and can be found on the back shelves of old-line repair shops. manifold into two “planes.” Each plane feeds two center cylinders on one bank and two end cylinders on the opposite bank. Most engine analyzers from the carburetor era feature a bank-to-bank “odd and even” cylinder balance test for V8 engines. See Photo 2.

To adjust idle mixture with the odd-even cylinder balance test, use the carb’s fast idle cam to set idle speed at about 1,500 rpm. Adjust the mixture on each idle mixture adjustment screw until each manifold plane exhibits an equal drop in engine speed as the odd- and even-numbered cylinders are cancelled. When finished with the odd/even balance test, squirt a little aerosol carb cleaner or propane into the carb intake. If the rpm increases, the idle mixture screws need to be backed out equally in 1/4-turn increments to richen the mixture. If the rpm decreases with the addition of carb cleaner, the screws need to be similarly turned in to lean the air/fuel mixture.

Carb Main Metering Tuning
Photo 3: This classic 406 cubic inch, 405 horsepower Ford engine from 1963 features three two-barrel carburetors, solid mechanical lifters, 11.25:1 compression ratio and dual-point ignition. This engine could accelerate a two-ton Ford sedan to 113 mph in 12.6 seconds in the quarter-mile. Unless an engine is being tuned under load on an engine or a chassis dynamometer, main metering tuning is largely determined by the color of the spark plugs, a seat-of-the-pants feel, or by time slips from the local drag strip. See Photo 3. In general, a carburetor jetted too lean will hesitate, stumble or lose power at cold ambient and coolant temperatures, but will run well at normal ambient and coolant temperatures. A carb jetted too rich will run well at cold ambient and coolant temperatures, but will suffer from excess fuel consumption, spark plug fouling and sluggish performance at normal engine coolant and ambient air temperatures.

In theory, changing barometric pressures shouldn’t affect carburetor fuel mixtures because the barometric pressure at the float bowls and venturi are equal. In reality, some carburetors require more re-jetting than others to compensate for changes in barometric pressure and ambient temperature. An old rule of thumb for Holley carburetors, for example, might be a one-step jet size reduction for each 2,000’ gain in altitude and a similar one-step reduction for each 35° increase in ambient temperature. On the other hand, some carburetors do quite nicely in a number of climate scenarios with standard jetting or a one- or two-step jet change.

Spark Plug Analysis
To use spark plug coloration for jetting purposes, it’s essential to know that spark plug insulator tip operating temperatures generally range from about 700° F at idle or part-throttle operation to about 1,500° F at full load. If the spark plug insulator runs too cold the majority of the time, it will tend to accumulate fuel and oil deposits. If the tip runs too hot, it can cause a glow-plug effect that will pre-ignite the fuel and possibly melt the piston centers.

Keep in mind that, on a correctly jetted carburetor, unleaded gasoline reduces tip coloration and that accurate tip coloration occurs only after extended driving times. The metal casing of a newly installed spark plug will show coloration first. After some miles are put on the spark plug, the center insulator will begin to “color” a light grey or tan.

If the engine is driven at full throttle on a set of new spark plugs and the engine is shut off and coasted to a stop, the ground electrode on a new spark plug should be wheat-colored on a correctly jetted carburetor. If the ground electrode has a blue coloration, the mixture is too lean. If the ground electrode is sooty, the mixture is too rich.

In addition, the coloration should start forming at the thicker, lower portion of the electrode insulator and build toward the tip. If the engine has been started cold, the insulator will turn black. Under load or extended speed, the insulator should begin to burn clean from the tip toward the bottom portion of the insulator. A good rule of thumb is to read the bottom of the insulator for long-term fuel mixture analysis and the tip for short-term fuel mixture analysis.

When selecting a spark plug heat range for a performance application, it’s important to reduce the spark plug heat range by one step for each one-point increase in compression ratio. For competition tuning, start with the coldest heat range possible because cold spark plugs “color” faster and present much less risk of causing expensive pre-ignition damage in the engine. If low-speed fouling occurs, increase the heat range in one-step increments until fouling is eliminated.

Never run higher than OE-recommended heat ranges in any performance application. Racing spark plugs, which are required in high-compression racing engines, have a very short ceramic insulator tip and a shortened ground electrode to enhance flame propagation. These spark plugs are designed, not for longevity, but rather to prevent preignition on a high-compression engine and should be used in any racing tuning application.

Spark Timing Terminology
Because the air/fuel ratio in the cylinder burns at a fixed rate as the engine speeds up, spark timing must be advanced to provide optimum power and fuel economy. Base spark advance is adjusted to produce enough vacuum in the intake manifold at idle speeds to properly operate the carburetor idle circuits and vacuum-operated accessories. In general, intake manifold vacuum on stock camshaft engines should range between 18” Hg and 22” Hg at sea level. Roughly 1” Hg of vacuum is lost per 1,000’ gain in altitude. So, at 8,000’, intake vacuum will be in the 12-14” Hg range. As the engine speeds up, the distributor must mechanically advance the spark roughly 10° per 1,000 rpm increase in crankshaft speed to allow the flame front to propagate from the spark plug throughout the combustion chamber. The rate of spark advance or “curve” depends solely upon the cylinder pressure generated by a combination of compression ratio, camshaft timing and cylinder head design. When an engine reaches approximately 4,000 crankshaft rpm, high combustion chamber turbulence generally eliminates the need for additional spark advance.

Base timing plus distributor spark advance equals total spark advance. To illustrate, a base timing of 12 crankshaft degrees plus a mechanical advance of 26 crankshaft degrees equals a 38° total advance. Most “wedge” combustion chamber designs with the spark plug placed at the side of the chamber on a 4” cylinder bore require from 36° to 38° of total advance. Hemispherical combustion chambers and “semi-hemi” chamber designs with the spark plug located at or near the center of the combustion chamber may require only 26-36° of total spark advance due to the reduced distance of flame propagation.

Small-bore engines also require less spark advance simply because of the reduced distance of flame propagation. Remember, too, that an increase in compression ratio generally requires a reduction in total spark advance. Changing from a 10:1 to 12:1 compression ratio might require a 2° reduction in total advance.

The vacuum advance on a mechanical distributor adds 10-15 crankshaft degrees to the mechanical timing curve and creates additional burn time for consuming the slow-burning, lean, fuel mixtures produced at part-throttle driving conditions. The vacuum advance merely enhances fuel economy and will not affect full-throttle performance unless the distributor advance plate is worn and won’t return to the zero advance position.

Tuning the Spark Advance
It’s very instructive to use a vacuum gauge to evaluate base timing. When the base timing is advanced too far, the idle quality will roughen as the intake vacuum reading peaks. When the base timing is retarded, the idle smoothes out as the vacuum reading drops several inches of mercury (” Hg). The reading at this point will, with the exception of a few post-emissions engines running retarded timing, be close to OE specification.

If the engine has a competition camshaft with valve timing overlap, the rough idle and poor low-speed driveability can be helped by adding to base timing and reducing mechanical spark advance. To illustrate, six crankshaft degrees can be added to base timing by reducing mechanical advance from 13 distributor degrees to 10 distributor degrees. Motorcraft distributors accomplish this by building a 10° and a 13° slot into their advance assemblies. General Motors and other distributors require advance-limiting bushings to achieve the same effect.

Because rich and lean air/fuel mixtures burn more slowly than does a stoichiometric mixture, over-advancing the spark timing will tend to improve the performance of a rich or lean engine by extending the burn time of the combustion event. On a lean engine, running an extended burn time can overheat and possibly melt the dome of the piston. On a correctly jetted engine, over-advanced spark timing will overheat the spark plug’s center and ground electrodes. The center insulator will also exhibit the characteristic salt-and-pepper appearance of small bits of melted aluminum piston being stuck to the spark plug insulator.

Over-advanced spark timing can cause the irritating “pinging” sound of detonation in a high-compression engine running on pump gasoline. Detonation occurs when the gasoline burns in an uncontrolled manner and causes an abrupt, destructive rise in cylinder pressure. Detonation is characterized by broken piston rings, ring lands and chipped spark plug insulators.

Elapsed Times and Trap Speeds
A carbureted engine can most effectively be precision-tuned at the local drag strip because the elapsed time and top speed of the vehicle can be very accurately measured. With that in mind, the conventional rule of thumb says that top speeds are influenced most by spark timing and that elapsed times are influenced most by air/fuel mixture ratios.

In any case, serious tuning mistakes can be avoided by limiting spark timing changes to 2° increments and carb jetting changes to one- or two-step increments. Keep in mind also that spark advance requirements generally should be reduced as air/fuel mixtures approach their optimum value. When an incremental adjustment of either fuel or spark yields no performance gain, optimum values have been achieved. While there is obviously latitude for discussion in these rules, they remain valid guidelines for any amateur precision tuner to follow in his quest for maximum performance from his carbureted street rod or collectible car.

You May Also Like

Bosch Releases 87 New Part Numbers in June

Bosch’s new part numbers cover 318 million vehicles in operation across North America.

Robert Bosch, LLC announced it has added 87 automotive aftermarket parts to its portfolio in June 2024, covering nearly 318 million vehicles in operation across North America. The new part numbers – which cover Domestic, European and Asian passenger and commercial vehicles – include 22 wiper part numbers, 35 rotating machines, 20 sensors, six spark plugs and more, according to the company.

Driveshaft, Axle and Drivetrain Noise FAQs

Follow along to learn more about these unwanted noises.

Driveshaft Diagnostics

The big challenge with late-model vehicles is the diversity of driveshafts. 

Nissan CVT Clutch Point Relearn Procedure

The Adaptive Shift Control delivers responsive and powerful acceleration.

Diagnostic Test Drive For Drivetrain

A driveshaft center bearing can fail due to the bearing and the rubber isolator.

Other Posts
Schaeffler Recognized as a GM 2023 Top Global Supplier

This is the fourth time Schaeffler has been honored with this award.

Schaeffler, ATSG Partner to Support Technical Education

Schaeffler will provide ATSG members with ongoing education and technical resources.

Catalytic Converter Replacement Rules

The conditions under which the catalytic converter was installed is of great importance to the part manufacturer.

catalytic converter
MEYLE Expands Electronics, Sensor Product Portfolio

The focus is on assistance systems and engine and transmission management, with more than 300 new part numbers.