Pulling Codes: Rough Road Data Not Available?

Pulling Codes: Rough Road Data Not Available?

A 1998 Chevrolet Blazer is looked at by the state to determine if the cost to repair this vehicle may exceed what many may deem reasonable. The owner of the vehicle has suffered some financial hardships and we have been asked to take a look at the vehicle.

This article will explore interpretation of what many have called “the descriptor” for diagnostic trouble codes. This case study is not a difficult one by any means, but important in reference to its understanding. A 1998 Chevrolet Blazer is looked at by the state to determine if the cost to repair this vehicle may exceed what many may deem reasonable. The owner of the vehicle has suffered some financial hardships and we have been asked to take a look at the vehicle. figure 1

This vehicle is a valuable education in more ways than one as I am teaching an emissions class for the state and it is always great to see how the techs respond to an actual failure event. I have attached a scan tool to the vehicle and am beginning to pull codes, the codes retrieved are as follows: P0300, P1380 and P1351. The screenshots in Figures 1-3 denote the code descriptions. 

The first code is evaluated and the Tech 2 misfire graphics screen shows a misfire on cylinder #5 and cylinder #1. A static figure 2compression test is performed on cylinder #5 with an in-cylinder pressure transducer, which shows that we have compression readings of 60 psi. The team makes a note of low compression for cylinder #5. 

We then proceeded to take a look at cylinder #1. The tech took out the spark plug for cylinder #1 and notes that the spark plug has a hairline crack down the center of the ceramic.

It was interesting to note how many on the evaluation team took on the characteristics of the famous Sherlock Holmes; it was the assurance that no further action was needed and that the process was all too figure 3elementary. I have seen this look all too often and respond by taking on the character of Dr. Watson. In order for all of us to have a better understanding of the codes that have set, I always review further the activity that caused the code to set.

I then proceeded to review cylinder #1 under cranking and running conditions with the transducer placed in the spark plug hole. The details of this case were now starting to be revealed; a cranking vacuum test was performed prior to the spark plug being taken out of cylinder #1. The vacuum waveform indicated that we did indeed have a mechanical issue with cylinder #2 as well. Review the waveform in Figure 4. figure 4

The waveform clearly shows we have a less than acceptable vacuum pull on cylinder #2; I am in search of the truth concerning this observation. I have placed the in-cylinder transducer inside cylinder #1 and will review the running test. I have provided the waveform for your review as well (Figure 5). 

I then decided that it was necessary to compare known good, so I obtained a pattern from cylinder #4, the pattern in Figure 6 shows what I saw. 

I then challenged the class to give me their analysis of what went wrong on cylinder #1. figure 5I have documented all data and have drawn a conclusion on this. I suspect the problem lies on the exhaust side, but I will challenge all of you to determine what happened in terms of the valvetrain. Please e-mail me your thoughts and let’s have a very good discussion on this. I have provided a piston position chart (Figure 7) to assist in the analysis of what may have happened in reference to this mechanical failure. 

The final analysis on this case study is the “misfire detected-rough road data not provided.” The students felt this may have been a crank angle relearn or an HVS distributor issue.figure 6 It was neither the case, the code set due to an ABS light being illuminated. Please e-mail me your thoughts at [email protected]. We will provide final thoughts on this in our next issue. This case will remain open until then. Figure 7

 

You May Also Like

MEMA Celebrates 120th Anniversary

MEMA said the milestone “underscores the association’s enduring legacy and its pivotal role in advancing the future of mobility and the interests of vehicle suppliers.”

MEMA, The Vehicle Suppliers Association, announced its 120th anniversary, a milestone it said "underscores the association's enduring legacy and its pivotal role in advancing the future of mobility and the interests of vehicle suppliers."

MEMA was founded on March 2, 1904, in Cleveland, Ohio, to represent the burgeoning automotive parts manufacturing industry. For the last 120 years, MEMA and its members have been at the forefront of advocacy, innovation and collaboration, the association said.

UniClutch Launches Clutch System in the United States

From Australian manufacturer Clutch Industries, UniClutch is a clutch system that delivers uncompromised performance.

MEMA Aftermarket Suppliers Becomes UAF Gold Lifetime Trustee

The partnership with UAF is a commitment to the future of the automotive aftermarket, MEMA Aftermarket Suppliers said.

Castrol Turns 125, Debuts New Market Strategy

As part of the new strategy, Castrol will explore opportunities in battery thermal management, digital and service solutions and data center immersion cooling.

FCS Introduces 18 New Numbers in February

The new release includes 4 shock absorbers and 14 suspension struts.

Other Posts

Philips Releases GoPure Advanced Automotive Air Purifier

It filters out 99% of bacteria and respiratory viruses and fits in the cupholder.

AP Emissions Releases New Part Numbers for February

The 12 new SKUs cover 6 million VIO.

MANN+HUMMEL NA Aftermarket Shows Right to Repair Support

Representatives from MANN+HUMMEL’s North American aftermarket brands recently visited Capitol Hill to express their support for H.R. 906.

Federated Upgrades Car Care Center Program

The enhanced program features updated signage, marketing support, image-enhancing tools, wearables, business management assistance and other information to help with day-to-day shop operations.