Pulling Codes: Advanced Misfire and Fuel Trim Analysis, Part 2

Pulling Codes: Advanced Misfire and Fuel Trim Analysis, Part 2

Contributing writer Carlton Banks continues with his series on Advanced Misfire and Fuel Trim Analysis, using fuel trims and oxygen sensor behavior to determine if the misfire activity is ignition, engine mechanical or fuel related. This article focuses on fuel-related misfires.


Each part of our series on Advanced Misfire and Fuel Trim Analysis documents the use of fuel trims and oxygen sensor behavior to determine if the misfire activity is ignition, engine mechanical or fuel related. Part 1 of our series focused on ignition-related misfires. Here, we’ll focus on fuel-related misfires.

We will address this from the viewpoint of moments in time to offer a deeper understanding of these concepts. As I ­mentioned in the last article, the first step is to ­visualize these failures from the beginning. Picture that a fuel-related misfire has occurred on a subject vehicle. Through our initial diagnostics, we find that it is a single cylinder misfire, and prior to failure, the pre-oxygen is switching and working as ­designed. The post-oxygen sensor is also working as designed and almost appears as a straight line when looked at per graphical data or a lab scope. figure 1: pre- and post-oxygen sensors under normal ­activity.

This time we’ll use a 2008 Buick Lucerne as an ­example. The figures from our scan tool will be used to show the activity.

Figure 1 denotes how the pre- and post-oxygen sensors may look on a subject vehicle prior to any type of misfire-related activity. figure 2: pre- and post-oxygen sensors under fuel-related misfire activity.

Figure 2 denotes the activity of the pre- and post-oxygen sensors at the initial point of fuel-related misfire activity. A close examination shows the pre-oxygen sensor went low, indicating that it saw oxygen in the exhaust stream at the very moment the misfire activity occurred. The post-oxygen sensor went low, indicating how the vehicle will have a tendency to run lean.

Note that at the very point of failure, the short-term fuel trim (STFT) will increase and, depending on design and strategy of the system, will show ­impressive numbers for short term. After the processor has acknowledged this, the resources of long-term fuel trim (LTFT) will work to get the short-term numbers back as close as possible to at or near zero. The end ­result is that after corrective action has taken place by the processor, there will be a significant impact on the total fuel trim adaptives (ST + LT). This analysis is based on a subject vehicle that has good fuel trim ­values to start with. A range of +/- 5% is optimal on many systems today, but a range of +/- 10% may be acceptable.

A great example is a vehicle that has a total correction of 15% prior to fault; you will have higher numbers once fuel-related misfire activity occurs. I have found that many vehicles with fuel-related misfire ­activity viewed after corrective action has taken place per the processor will normally show numbers that can add to double digits. This difference is noted in reference to ignition misfires that show numbers that may add to single digits.

Now, let’s further our education by taking a look at our case study, using a 1998 Pontiac Bonneville with ­multiple misfire activity.


1998 Pontiac Bonneville with Multiple Misfires figure 3

Upon review of this failure, it shows that a STFT of -18% was noted and a LTFT of -20%, this is a total correction of -38%. See Figure 3. This is a significant impact on the total fuel trim correction (ST + LT). The misfire activity appears to be on cylinders 1, 2 and 3. See Figure 4. Based on service records, we found that a fuel pressure regulator was replaced prior to our analysis.

The diaphragm inside the fuel pressure regulator was noted to have ruptured. This was evident after the vacuum line was disconnected from the fuel pressure regulator. There was seepage that could be seen prior to pulling the vacuum line off. figure 4

The engine vacuum had drawn fuel in the crankcase of the engine and the oil was saturated with gasoline. When we took the dipstick out, oil literally ran off of the dipstick tube, offering some proof that the oil was diluted. You could also smell gasoline on the dipstick tube. figure 5

We have found a resource online with misfire software; go to www.acemisfire.com for more ­information on it. We decided to try this software along with the FirstLook Engine Diagnostic Pulse ­Sensor. See Figures 5-7. figure 6

According to online sources, by mapping the pulse waves generated by the engine, FirstLook (used along with your lab scope) can be used to quickly spot failures in the engine system. Also, by using a trigger, you can spot these failures to specific cylinders. On those cars with accessible fuel pressure regulators, FirstLook allows you to see the pressure drop in the fuel rail caused by the injectors as they fire.Figure 7

We found it to be very helpful in drawing a conclusion to repair.

After the oil was changed on our Bonneville, the fuel trims returned to their normal operating parameters.

This Pulling Codes case is now closed. 


You May Also Like

Autoshop Solutions Partners with BlueRecruit

The two are working together to help bring exceptional technicians, mechanics, and service writers to Autoshop customers’ garages.

Autoshop Solutions has partnered with BlueRecruit, to help their customers find the right talent for their shops.

“We could not be more excited to partner with Autoshop Solutions. Daily, we hear from garage owners of the difficulty they are experiencing finding and connecting with talent. That is why this partnership allows us to better serve the thousands of garages that know and trust our friends at Autoshop Solutions. We could not find a better industry partner to work with,” said Rich Camacho, CEO of BlueRecruit. “Our mission at BlueRecruit is to provide America’s workers a revolutionary path to success, and this partnership is a perfect step on the way to achieving that goal.”

Honda, Ascend Elements partner on EV battery materials

Ascend Elements has recycled used lithium-ion batteries for American Honda Motor Co. since 2021.

Bosch Releases 52 Aftermarket Parts in Q1

The new Bosch products includes three braking parts, 16 fuel and water pumps, two ignition coils, 30 sensors and one fuel injector.

BCA Bearings Announces 2023 Summer Cruisin’ Promotion

The Summer Cruisin’ promotion runs from April 1 through June 15, 2023.

Standard Motor Products’ ABS Sensors Line Expands

Standard offers more than 2,600 ABS Sensors fitting import and domestic vehicle

Other Posts

Mercedes 4MATIC Diagnostics

The Mercedes-Benz 4MATIC all-wheel drive (AWD) systems have been around for a while now.

ADAS Calibration Aborts

Knowing the common “hiccups” can save you time and money.

Struts and Memory Steer

We can summarize the cause of memory steer in one word: binding.

Manual Transmission Service

Parts that wear out must be replaced.